{recipe, kind of} I Tried Those Healthy 2 Ingredient Banana-Oat Breakfast “Cookies” So You Don’t Have To

Wouldn’t it be great, amazing, stupendous even, if you could make delicious cookies using only bananas and oats? It would, right? You could eat like 10 cookies but in reality all you ate was a banana and half a cup of oats. Because you are so smart and so healthy and good at life.

banana cookie

Sadly, I’m here to report that this is another one of those recipes going around Pinterest that seems too good to be true, and really isn’t good at all. It’s hard to believe, because recipes like this engender so!!! Many!!!! Comments!!! With!!! So!!! Many!!! Exclamation points!!!!!!! extolling their virtues.

I don’t know what it is about me and silly Pinterest recipes that call for only bananas, but I can’t stop trying them, even though I know in my heart of hearts they will fail miserably. Much like the one-ingredient banana ice cream debacle, I had a feeling that these would be doomed from the start, but I went ahead and made them anyway. I had to try them for myself to confirm that–shockingly–bananas and oats smushed together and baked in the shape of cookies do not actually become delicious cookies. Apparently I put way too much faith in the magical powers of flat, circular shapes and 350 degrees, thinking that somehow, just maybe, subjecting bananas and oats to these conditions would have transformative effects. But all this process turns out is flat, chewy little wads of banana and oats.

I think I’m worried that I could be missing out on something that is really delicious and healthy by not giving these kinds of recipes a try. But they never work. I mean, don’t get me started on the time I tried this chickpea cookie dough dip (what was I thinking?) which was probably the grossest thing I have ever tasted (and that includes the time I sort of accidentally attended a nose-to-tail dinner and the dessert involved, nay, featured, the lungs of some poor farm animal.)

I tried my darnedest to doctor these up, in hopes of a better result. So I made three varieties- original recipe, vanilla and cinnamon, and ginger molasses. Fail, fail, and fail. Still gross. It’s mostly the texture that is so unappealing, followed closely by the taste. I used so much ginger that the ginger molasses “cookies” were actually pretty spicy, and yet still unsalvageable as something you’d actually want to eat.

However. 

There was one person in my house who loved all three flavors and devoured the whole batch in a day. He is all of 11 months old, so as you can imagine, his palate is highly refined in terms of both texture and taste. I mean, we are talking about a person who literally chews up a Goldfish cracker, spits it out as a slimy trail of orange goo, and then scoops it up and eats it again. Kind of like a dog! So, I bet dogs would like these too.

If curiosity is killing you, or you just want to train your small child to eat terrible-tasting cookies for breakfast, here is the recipe:

  • Smash up a very ripe banana in a bowl.
  • Add 1/2 cup quick cooking oats and mix well.
  • Why? Why are you making them?
  • Add mix-ins as an attempt to make them edible. It probably won’t work but have fun with it anyway.
  • Form into cookie shapes on a cookie sheet that is greased or covered with parchment.
  • Seriously. Stahp.
  • Bake at 350 for 15 minutes.
  • Taste one. Feed remainder to toddler or dog. If neither is available, throw in the compost bin.
Print Friendly

9 comments

1 RookieMom Whitney { 02.15.13 at 2:41 pm }

I just fell in love with you all over again. I saw these on the Interwebz and was like, “How is that possible? I’ll just ask Karen if that’s possible, because I’m sure in pastry chef school they would have told her if all that flour and butter was just, like, to make everything look harder than it is.”
RookieMom Whitney recently posted..A long-winded tale of two bunk beds

2 Karen { 02.15.13 at 7:23 pm }

@Whitney Aww, thanks!

3 camille { 02.18.13 at 6:55 pm }

Who needs a special kind of cookie to eat for breakfast anyway? If I want to eat cookies for breakfast, I will damn well eat cookies for breakfast. I’m a grownup and I can. I don’t need to trick myself.
camille recently posted..Three Cheese Baked Tortellini

4 Karen { 02.18.13 at 9:38 pm }

@Camille haha! Love it! You are so right!

5 Dana { 02.19.13 at 12:57 pm }

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Dip: so awful. So terribly terribly awful. Why has everyone jumped on this bandwagon of making treat food awful by hiding more nutrient laden food to it? Food that is good for you is good and often fabulous tasting. Food that isn’t good for you is often super tasty, and you can eat it as long as you have the sense of mind to know when to stop.

Stop hiding spinach and broccoli in my brownies! If I want to eat a brownie, I want it to be made of chocolate, butter, sugar, eggs and some sort of flour. I really enjoy broccoli, I really enjoy spinach. I’m not going to be pleased if you hide those vegetables in my brownies. Don’t say that you can’t tell the difference. :P

Why make treats less pleasant? Can’t we just eat mindfully and treat ourselves sometimes?
Dana recently posted..Preserve Making Nerdiness

6 Dana { 02.19.13 at 12:58 pm }

Also, high five to Camille!
Dana recently posted..Preserve Making Nerdiness

7 Karen { 02.21.13 at 4:06 pm }

@Dana – indeed!!

8 corinne { 02.27.13 at 12:18 pm }

This was hilarious. Thank you.

I’ve found that a good mix-in is shredded coconut. Adds a nice dimension to the texture and the sweetness, helps hold them together.

Still though.. yeah.
corinne recently posted..Atwater Elementary

9 Karen { 02.28.13 at 8:06 pm }

@corinne – thank you! I will try that. Or not. ;)

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge